The collective consciousness of choirs

Wimbledon Choral Society

Wimbledon Choral Society (Photo: BBC)

After last night’s final choral rehearsal of Britten’s Spring Symphony I have been contemplating the idea of the collective consciousness. When it works, it is magnificent. The choir seems as if it is one being, breathing and singing together to produce a glorious sound that transports the audience. It is one of the aims of a good choir and the feeling it brings when it is done right is one of the amazing aspects of singing with a group of people.

When it goes wrong, it can be heart-thumpingly scary. My former choir, Wimbledon Choral Society, have been lucky enough to sing at the Royal British Legion’s Festival of Remembrance for a number of years. It really is a privilege to sing to a capacity Royal Albert Hall and take part in the service to remember those who have served in the armed forces. Then there is the additional thrill of trying to spot yourself on TV behind one of Katherine Jenkins’ frocks. From a musical point of view the repertoire is not usually challenging, with straightforward hymns plus oohing and ahhing in the background to support the soloists.

On one particular occasion, the soloist was Hayley Westenra. For whatever reason, we ran out of time to rehearse one of her pieces on the day. Trying to fit in a full dress rehearsal plus both performances was clearly stretching the BBC’s schedule to the limit, and it was decided that it would be fine to just perform it. Now, most choral directors would like to think that their choir was capable of rising to the challenge of sight-singing a relatively simple piece during a performance. However, there were a few things working against us:
1. We had neither seen nor heard the piece before (it was a new arrangement)
2. The music we were given contained only our own parts (ie the sopranos had only the soprano part) without any cues from the soloist or band or other choral parts
3. The piece was written in 4 and, unbeknownst to us, was being conducted in 2
4. The music did not follow the usual pattern of these pieces where we happily oohed and aahed behind the soloist (and therefore could get away with a multitude of sins). As it turned out, the structure was Hayley sings, choir sings, Hayley sings, choir sings…

You could feel the collective confusion as Hayley began singing and we all started wondering where on earth we were in relation to the music we had in front of us. Normally, counting bars is not an issue, but it turns out to be a major problem when the conductor is beating in a different time signature to the one that you think you are in. Consequently, we were thoroughly lost when Hayley finished her verse and turned expectantly to the 200-strong choir behind her… Collective panic. Immediately followed by collective stiff upper lip, collective putting on a brave face and collective singing something in the chord. Never have I been so glad to get to the end of a piece. Collectively, we just couldn’t get it right (although the plus side of this type of piece is that no one knows what you should have been singing anyway).

Back to the present day and the Britten requires a certain amount of collective consciousness, particularly with regards to pitching the first note of new movements. For those of us without the gift of perfect pitch, being told to find your note from a fourth above the tuba or from an orchestral chord that sounds like the composer’s cat wandered over the manuscript is definitely a leap of faith. Next week’s heart thumping moments will be in the seconds before we sing, as we hope our collective consciousness carries us to choral greatness … and the correct notes.

The CBSO Chorus will be performing Britten’s Spring Symphony with the CBSO conducted by Ed Gardner at Symphony Hall, Birmingham on 17 and 19 September.


One response

  1. Pingback: It’s easy as 1, 2, 3… | Happiness is singing in a choir

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s